
Desertcart purchases this item on your behalf and handles shipping, customs, and support to Botswana.
A magisterial, single-volume history of the greatest conflict the world has ever known by our foremost military historian. The Second World War began in August 1939 on the edge of Manchuria and ended there exactly six years later with the Soviet invasion of northern China. The war in Europe appeared completely divorced from the war in the Pacific and China, and yet events on opposite sides of the world had profound effects. Using the most up-to-date scholarship and research, Beevor assembles the whole picture in a gripping narrative that extends from the North Atlantic to the South Pacific and from the snowbound steppe to the North African Desert. Although filling the broadest canvas on a heroic scale, Beevor's The Second World War never loses sight of the fate of the ordinary soldiers and civilians whose lives were crushed by the titanic forces unleashed in this, the most terrible war in history. Review: Per demitizzare la guerra - Una grande storia, accurata, documentata, che descrive le grandi battaglie, le immani sofferenze dei civili, molte vicende individuali. Accanto a questo, gli errori, l'opportunismo, le ambiguitร di militari, politici, dittatori. Non si salva nessuno. Infine, le conseguenze della guerra. La storia senza fronzoli della peggiore fra le guerre per ripudiare ogni tipo di guerra. Review: Another Beevor "must read" classic, but leaves me with some issues.... - I'm a fan of Beevor and pre-ordered this book many months ago (at a good price, which desertcart honoured, I must add!). I was not disappointed - the subject matter is fascinating, the style is crisp and relevant, and the balance is superb for a single-tome WWII book. So, let me explain why this book is a "must read", before making some criticisms of it. And then think about whether this book is better than "All Hell Let Loose" by Max Hastings. I. Why is this book a "must read"? WWII shaped the world, in which we live. This includes the demise of the British empire, the major shifts in the global power balance (emergence of USA, USSR), the expansion of the totalitarian Soviet regime, the rise to power of communists in several countries notably China but not Italy or Greece, social changes in most countries as old mantras were challenged (eg. British class system, Russian soldiers seeing prosperity in Western Europe) and the roots of the Cold War, various civil wars and so many other aspects. The direct impact of WWII was huge of course. Some 60 million people perished (equivalent to c100,000 per page of the very thick book), in some countries a substantial portion of the population. Countless millions were raped, wounded, terrorised or impoverished. Whole segments of the population were annihilated, in the Holocaust and ethnic cleansing in several regions, while land boundaries were moved - in China and Poland for example - and whole populations relocated on political grounds. The very nature of WWII makes it tangible and relevant to us all. Even though the technology of war is basic, it is distinguishably modern. The societies that fought were not so different from our own, yet proved capable of such barbarism, stupidity, courage, cruelty and self-sacrifice that we can learn a little about ourselves by looking at the experiences of the participants of WWII. Anthony Beevor covers this ground extraordinarily well. The book is well structured and balanced. It is global, covering the main theatres of the war, mainly China, Asia-Pacific, Western Europe, Eastern Europe and North Africa. Beevor breaks the chapters into chronological chunks and flips from one main theatre to another. This works well as a structure, and enables the international balance to be achieved. He also seems fairly even-handed and objective, pointing out the strengths and failures of the main protagonists. This breadth and balance is rare for WWII books. Beevor is authoritative, lucid, accessible and, quite frankly, such a good story-teller that he is far superior to any other historian that I have read. He uses diaries and anecdotes to bring dry chronologies to life and illustrate the subject matter in a very human way. I can't fault the content, and even learnt some new facts, such as Hitler wanting to use the Canary Islands as a base for bombing the eastern USA at some point in time. II. Criticisms My biggest concern throughout the book was that it actually had very little depth, even at 780 pages and 2kg in weight! The Battle of Britain is covered in 6 pages and the development and dropping of atomic bombs barely takes 2 pages. I've decided that a single-tome WWII book is always going to leave the fascinated reader thirsting for more, so I can't fault him for it. Examples of topics that I am now going to try to read more about, which Beevor barely touches: - What was going on in say the USA or UK during the war? - How did post-war reconstruction get arranged in say Japan, Russia, China? - How did Mao Tse-Tung get to power in China (a real gap in my knowledge, I'm ashamed to say) - What were the long-term psychological impacts of the war on those who were maltreated, especially children, or wounded or bereaved? - How did the industrial production work in war-time, eg. development of new aircraft, production of iron/steel/tanks/ships, and how did agriculture function? I have a few minor moans about this particular book. 1. Surprisingly, Beevor is sometimes lyrical without need. On p116, he writes: "...in spite of the numbers who had been wounded by German aircraft strafing and bombing the packed roads. Once again it was the women who bore the brunt of the disaster and who rose to the occasion with self-sacrifice and calm. The men were the ones in tears of despair." This reads too much like a "historical novel", in my opinion 2. There are some very generic facts that get tagged to certain stories but not others, eg during the forced march people fell exhausted by the wayside and perished, mothers wept and people looted. I wonder whether a thematic approach ("Clothes", "Looting", "Nutrition") would be an alternative or supplementary approach to writing such a history book (I've read such a one on medieval England, and it was great). 3. He's obviously more comfortable with areas he's written about before! Stalingrad, Berlin, Crete are all beautifully covered. But the Asian sections didn't work for me, I felt he didn't put as much effort into bringing them to life, and I felt my eyes skipping through them, longing for the next section in another geography. 4. The start of the book (ie. WWII started in the far east, not when Hitler invaded Poland) has grabbed a lot of people's attention but is spurious and arbitrary. Why do we need a starting point and why is his one better than others? 5. Beevor is light on messages, big visionary interpretations and so on. The last two pages of musing are appalling: muddled, superficial, unconvincing. III. CONCLUSION AND COMPARISON WITH HASTINGS' AHLL It's a great book on a great topic by a great author. Five stars for sure and MUST READ for sure too. It's not daunting despite being 780 pages, because it's well written and presented. I wonder whether it's a coincidence that it came out hot on the heels of Hastings' book...?!? As for comparisons with "All Hell Let Loose", they are very similar in scope and quality. Hastings is slightly more of a yarn (=accessible), less authoritative, better in Asia and better at picking up big topics, like the superb observation that democracies couldn't wage total war whereas Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union could. Beevor is more authoritative and has better feeling for the Nazi/Soviet elements of the war. But, on reflection, Beevor isn't as good as Hastings at a single-tome WWII book - he's much better when he does a deep-dive and gives himself the room to explore the history via diaries and other convincing details. Read it, enjoy (if that's the right word) and reflect!
| Best Sellers Rank | #107,776 in Books ( See Top 100 in Books ) #74 in Military History #781 in World History #4,148 in Textbooks & Study Guides |
| Customer Reviews | 4.7 out of 5 stars 1,381 Reviews |
M**I
Per demitizzare la guerra
Una grande storia, accurata, documentata, che descrive le grandi battaglie, le immani sofferenze dei civili, molte vicende individuali. Accanto a questo, gli errori, l'opportunismo, le ambiguitร di militari, politici, dittatori. Non si salva nessuno. Infine, le conseguenze della guerra. La storia senza fronzoli della peggiore fra le guerre per ripudiare ogni tipo di guerra.
A**Y
Another Beevor "must read" classic, but leaves me with some issues....
I'm a fan of Beevor and pre-ordered this book many months ago (at a good price, which Amazon honoured, I must add!). I was not disappointed - the subject matter is fascinating, the style is crisp and relevant, and the balance is superb for a single-tome WWII book. So, let me explain why this book is a "must read", before making some criticisms of it. And then think about whether this book is better than "All Hell Let Loose" by Max Hastings. I. Why is this book a "must read"? WWII shaped the world, in which we live. This includes the demise of the British empire, the major shifts in the global power balance (emergence of USA, USSR), the expansion of the totalitarian Soviet regime, the rise to power of communists in several countries notably China but not Italy or Greece, social changes in most countries as old mantras were challenged (eg. British class system, Russian soldiers seeing prosperity in Western Europe) and the roots of the Cold War, various civil wars and so many other aspects. The direct impact of WWII was huge of course. Some 60 million people perished (equivalent to c100,000 per page of the very thick book), in some countries a substantial portion of the population. Countless millions were raped, wounded, terrorised or impoverished. Whole segments of the population were annihilated, in the Holocaust and ethnic cleansing in several regions, while land boundaries were moved - in China and Poland for example - and whole populations relocated on political grounds. The very nature of WWII makes it tangible and relevant to us all. Even though the technology of war is basic, it is distinguishably modern. The societies that fought were not so different from our own, yet proved capable of such barbarism, stupidity, courage, cruelty and self-sacrifice that we can learn a little about ourselves by looking at the experiences of the participants of WWII. Anthony Beevor covers this ground extraordinarily well. The book is well structured and balanced. It is global, covering the main theatres of the war, mainly China, Asia-Pacific, Western Europe, Eastern Europe and North Africa. Beevor breaks the chapters into chronological chunks and flips from one main theatre to another. This works well as a structure, and enables the international balance to be achieved. He also seems fairly even-handed and objective, pointing out the strengths and failures of the main protagonists. This breadth and balance is rare for WWII books. Beevor is authoritative, lucid, accessible and, quite frankly, such a good story-teller that he is far superior to any other historian that I have read. He uses diaries and anecdotes to bring dry chronologies to life and illustrate the subject matter in a very human way. I can't fault the content, and even learnt some new facts, such as Hitler wanting to use the Canary Islands as a base for bombing the eastern USA at some point in time. II. Criticisms My biggest concern throughout the book was that it actually had very little depth, even at 780 pages and 2kg in weight! The Battle of Britain is covered in 6 pages and the development and dropping of atomic bombs barely takes 2 pages. I've decided that a single-tome WWII book is always going to leave the fascinated reader thirsting for more, so I can't fault him for it. Examples of topics that I am now going to try to read more about, which Beevor barely touches: - What was going on in say the USA or UK during the war? - How did post-war reconstruction get arranged in say Japan, Russia, China? - How did Mao Tse-Tung get to power in China (a real gap in my knowledge, I'm ashamed to say) - What were the long-term psychological impacts of the war on those who were maltreated, especially children, or wounded or bereaved? - How did the industrial production work in war-time, eg. development of new aircraft, production of iron/steel/tanks/ships, and how did agriculture function? I have a few minor moans about this particular book. 1. Surprisingly, Beevor is sometimes lyrical without need. On p116, he writes: "...in spite of the numbers who had been wounded by German aircraft strafing and bombing the packed roads. Once again it was the women who bore the brunt of the disaster and who rose to the occasion with self-sacrifice and calm. The men were the ones in tears of despair." This reads too much like a "historical novel", in my opinion 2. There are some very generic facts that get tagged to certain stories but not others, eg during the forced march people fell exhausted by the wayside and perished, mothers wept and people looted. I wonder whether a thematic approach ("Clothes", "Looting", "Nutrition") would be an alternative or supplementary approach to writing such a history book (I've read such a one on medieval England, and it was great). 3. He's obviously more comfortable with areas he's written about before! Stalingrad, Berlin, Crete are all beautifully covered. But the Asian sections didn't work for me, I felt he didn't put as much effort into bringing them to life, and I felt my eyes skipping through them, longing for the next section in another geography. 4. The start of the book (ie. WWII started in the far east, not when Hitler invaded Poland) has grabbed a lot of people's attention but is spurious and arbitrary. Why do we need a starting point and why is his one better than others? 5. Beevor is light on messages, big visionary interpretations and so on. The last two pages of musing are appalling: muddled, superficial, unconvincing. III. CONCLUSION AND COMPARISON WITH HASTINGS' AHLL It's a great book on a great topic by a great author. Five stars for sure and MUST READ for sure too. It's not daunting despite being 780 pages, because it's well written and presented. I wonder whether it's a coincidence that it came out hot on the heels of Hastings' book...?!? As for comparisons with "All Hell Let Loose", they are very similar in scope and quality. Hastings is slightly more of a yarn (=accessible), less authoritative, better in Asia and better at picking up big topics, like the superb observation that democracies couldn't wage total war whereas Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union could. Beevor is more authoritative and has better feeling for the Nazi/Soviet elements of the war. But, on reflection, Beevor isn't as good as Hastings at a single-tome WWII book - he's much better when he does a deep-dive and gives himself the room to explore the history via diaries and other convincing details. Read it, enjoy (if that's the right word) and reflect!
D**M
the definitive history of the most horrific war in history
Library shelves are now jammed with books about the second world war. These histories of the war seem to become more nuanced, better written, more insightful and more absorbing with each year. Anthony Beevor's massive story of the war, The Second World War, stands at the pinnacle of these histories. Beevor is trained in the arts and theories of war. He studied the art of warfare under John Keegan, one of the greatest military minds of the 20th Century, served in the British military, and is married to the daughter of Duff Cooper, one of the major figures in the Churchill government during the war. Beevor started his literary life as a novelist and his major works, including this one, read like novels. Beevor tells the many stories of the war always with one eye on the personal experiences of the combatants, frequently hideous experiences, but so important to understanding the emotional side of the century's greatest conflict. Beevor sets this history apart from most other histories of the war in his ability to connect events in widely zones. For example, Hitler's insistence on securing German dominance of the Balkan states in the early spring of 1941, following his rapid conquest of France, led to what turned out to be a fatal delay in the invasion of Russia. This invasion started in June 1941 but was stalled and eventually blunted by the lethal Russian winter campaign of 1941-42. In addition, the entry into the war of the United States after its naval forces were bombed at Pearl Harbor in December 1941 enabled Stalin to shift vital forces from Russia's Far Eastern theater back to the Western front, reinforcing the defenses against the German machine. The story of the Russian campaign, probably the single most important engagement of the war, is made more complete by Beevor's analysis of the complex events enabling Russia to fight an increasingly effective war against Germany. Beevor treats each major battle in the war with great clarity and almost novelistic skill. The Luftwaffe attacks on Britain in the late summer of 1940, when the fate of Britain was in the hands of very few pilots flying very few airplanes, has been told many times but none to my knowledge raised the reader's tension and fears as well as this account. This was a battle that Hitler desperately wanted to win. His attempt to break Britain, if it had succeeded, could have changed the course of the war. Europe was the bloodiest theater of the war but the Far Eastern campaigns, in which Japan assembled as violent a war machine as anything in Europe, were equally thrilling and important. Beevor tells the story of the American march across the Pacific, island hopping towards the Japanese homeland, with the same sense of drama and uncertainty as in the European story. The Japanese had occupied and subjugated most of China, they controlled most of Indonesian and the Burmese peninsula. Their navy was strong and well-trained. Gradually, however, the ability of the Americans to build ever-greater numbers of battleships and destroyers, ultimately ending in the release of two atomic bombs into two major Japanese cities overcame the initial Japanese advantages. By early 1943, the Allies began bombing the German homeland and the Russian army, having staved off the German near-occupation of Stalingrad, began its gradual grinding down of the German army. Beevor, who has written a marvelous history of the battle of Stalingrad, is able to convey a sense of the horror and desperation of this battle that few historians could convey. This is a great history of a complex and horrific war. If only one book can be read on this war - given a list of books that now number into the tens of thousands - one could not imagine a better single book that tells the story more completely. It is a gripping history.
B**A
Recived undamaged product that's nice
Good quality
D**D
The ultimate book about WWII
I consider this is the ULTIMATE book to learn about WWII. It covers all the conflict from beginning to end in a take that reads like a teacher who is passionately telling you an interesting story. Well documented, rigorously researched, but narrated with the passion of a storyteller.
Trustpilot
2 weeks ago
2 months ago